Re: Creationism, Myth and Catastrophism
Posted: Mon Oct 26, 2020 12:54 am
22588
VENUS DIDN'T STEAL MARS' ATMOSPHERE?
PS, I just found that Cardona seems to have doubted Talbott's above idea that Venus appeared oval-shaped when the Saturn system started to become unstable. It's in his article, The Evolution of the Cosmogonic Egg in Aeon III:5 (May 1994), a catastrophist journal. I only read a brief part of it, but he gave reasons for doubting that Venus should have appeared oval-shaped. The title suggests that it was Saturn that was oval or egg-shaped at least for a time. So far, I'm not finding any solid leads about what happened to Jupiter, Venus and Mars as the Saturn system broke up. A smoking gun would be nice to find. I guess Osiris was Saturn when Saturn died and looked like a mummy. I hope to find evidence of a transition from Saturn to Jupiter. I'm still working here: https://futureschool.boards.net/post/182/thread
Here's an interesting contradiction of Talbott from Catastrophism.com in a search for "Jupiter replace Saturn.
The Opening of The Mouth Ritual - Part II [Aeon]
... believes Osiris was Saturn. [69] Instead, he now surmises that Osiris was actually Jupiter, which planet replaced Saturn behind which it had been shielded from mortal eyes. To him, this change of polar planets constituted the re-born sun-god. My main objection, here, is that one cannot ignore the unlikely celestial dynamics involved in having Jupiter replace Saturn in a new polar configuration with Venus, Mars and Earth still aligned below it. How could such a massive celestial body as Saturn get out of the line-up so easily without disrupting the other bodies? More importantly, how could Saturn have then disappeared entirely, as it must have done for observers not to see that it
VENUS DIDN'T STEAL MARS' ATMOSPHERE?
PS, I just found that Cardona seems to have doubted Talbott's above idea that Venus appeared oval-shaped when the Saturn system started to become unstable. It's in his article, The Evolution of the Cosmogonic Egg in Aeon III:5 (May 1994), a catastrophist journal. I only read a brief part of it, but he gave reasons for doubting that Venus should have appeared oval-shaped. The title suggests that it was Saturn that was oval or egg-shaped at least for a time. So far, I'm not finding any solid leads about what happened to Jupiter, Venus and Mars as the Saturn system broke up. A smoking gun would be nice to find. I guess Osiris was Saturn when Saturn died and looked like a mummy. I hope to find evidence of a transition from Saturn to Jupiter. I'm still working here: https://futureschool.boards.net/post/182/thread
Here's an interesting contradiction of Talbott from Catastrophism.com in a search for "Jupiter replace Saturn.
The Opening of The Mouth Ritual - Part II [Aeon]
... believes Osiris was Saturn. [69] Instead, he now surmises that Osiris was actually Jupiter, which planet replaced Saturn behind which it had been shielded from mortal eyes. To him, this change of polar planets constituted the re-born sun-god. My main objection, here, is that one cannot ignore the unlikely celestial dynamics involved in having Jupiter replace Saturn in a new polar configuration with Venus, Mars and Earth still aligned below it. How could such a massive celestial body as Saturn get out of the line-up so easily without disrupting the other bodies? More importantly, how could Saturn have then disappeared entirely, as it must have done for observers not to see that it