Unread post
by BecomingTesla » Thu Oct 08, 2015 1:26 pm
Okay, let's just get this done and over with.
(1) My understanding of your hypothesis has absolutely nothing to do with my post regarding your behavior. You are out of line. And no, I may not be a mod so ultimately its not my call, but if anyone else wants to chime in, they're welcome to. You don't get to come in here and recommend censorship because people here disagree with Thornhill, and find his behavior as a poor reflection on the community.
(2) I challenge you do disprove Newton's heuristic for gravitation, or for that matter, why don't you go ahead and disprove general relativity as well? Because here is the issue you don't seem to understand - if you can't approximate and demonstrate your hypothesis, empirically, as being *physically* possible with an actual experimental setup, then your hypothesis is in the exact same position as these two theories, which have hundreds upon hundreds of experiments to back them up, over the last ~300 years.
No one here is impressed because you've got a theory that seems mathematically sound. You know who else produced mathematically solid theoretical arguments? Arthur Schuster. Know who he was? The man who mathematically proved that Birkeland's theory of the aurora was impossible. I'm pretty sure everyone in this forum knows how that turned out, don't they.
*Everyone* who is here, is here because mathematics isn't enough. Everyone here questions the Big Bang, dark matter, GR, etc. *because* they don't believe that mathematics is enough. If they did, they'd be studying astrophysics at university, instead of coming here and teaching themselves. No one here has to disprove anything, or subscribe to any hypothesis/theory/framework that *is not* proven experimentally, and that includes your theory. And hey, it could very well be correct! If you think you've got a fantastic hypothesis, then go build a lab and prove it. That's the exact thing Birkeland did, and Alfven, and Tesla, and Faraday, and every other electrician that brought us here.