Hi GC, Krakonis,
Hi Krackonis,
You wrote:
Plato was a barely conscious human at the beginning of consciousness.
Eh? I'm guessing that you got that from Jaynes?
This is not a correct interpretation of Jaynes' theory. Plato would have been of the same level of development or potential as any modern man. Conciousness is a means of authorization, a being either has it or does not. The error of the above quote lies in the implied assumption that there is a slow evolution or growth of conciousness, ergo, a modern man's level of conciousness must be "higher" or more developed than a Classic Greek.
But Jaynes' theory is that conciousness arose spontaneously in humans around the world as a result of some (unspecified by him, remember that he was basically a uniformitarian) catastrophic occurrence. Before that, authorization came from an interior voice that was thought to be the orders of a god, king, chief, ancestor, etc. These voices now, while still potentially within all of us, manifest themselves at times of extreme stress or in schizophrenics.
A Greek, such as Plato, of circa the 5th BCE would have the same abilities and potentials for creating "mindspace" (through the use of analogies and metaphors) in which his "analog I" could operate as would any thinker of today. In other words the same mechanism would exist in any concious human, either then or now. Again, it is either there or is not there. To Jaynes conciousness is an abstract operative, similar to a mathematical concept, it is not of a concrete existence. That is my understanding of Jaynes.
If there is a "next step" in the development of conciousness, we have yet to see it.
nick c
PS
My apologies for any derailment of this thread, but I thought that the implication that Jaynes advocated a slow evolution of conciousness since its' emergence needed to be corrected. This thread has the Plato/Atlantis connection, and then the idea that Plato may have been bicameral or partially bicameral in the Jaynesian sense, which needed to be clarified. If there are any other comments perhaps they should go on a Julian Jaynes thread:
http://www.thunderbolts.info/wp/forum/phpB ... ian+jaynes